Paleo Mama Bakery

Kimberly Alan

5.02 months ago

This place is even better than the photos on their web site- sooo good. Had the chocolate peanut butter pie- so silky, great flavor.

Dawn Mullarney

5.03 months ago

Someone did a little birthday research and found this gem, and wow, I am grateful the did! I was surprised with birthday treats that are gluten free and dairy free, and I'm not exaggerating when I say they melted in my mouth! Honestly you would never know they were gluten free and dairy free! Being able to celebrate my birthday with an actual treat, also one that I didn't have to make, meant more than I can say!!! So happy to have something this amazing in our community! I also started following them online and discovered they also carry items at Woodmans, and the number of options they offer is impressive! I have already sent their info to a few friends and told them to start following and checking out everything they have! A hidden gem :) happy I am aware of now!

Rebecca Zimmerman

5.07 months ago

I eat keto when possible, and Paleo Mama Bakery has amazing keto-friendly goods. They are as beautiful as baked goods from traditional bakeries, and they taste delicious! A lot of the time, I find keto-friendly frosted goods to be really heavy, but these are not as heavy as others I've tried. I've even gone out of my way to get a birthday cake from here (I live almost 150 miles away) because they are perfect for special occasions when people are eating low-carb/keto. I've attached a photo of a slice of the keto carrot cake, which was delicious!

Karolina Nowak

5.08 months ago

Paleo Mama is my absolute MUST stop whenever I visit Madison! There aren't many bakeries out there that cater to keto diets so this spot is a rare gem in my book by catering to gluten-free, keto, paleo, and vegan diets. They have an amazing selection - and not just of their own items! They also sell packaged products from reputable brands such as ChocZero and Good Good just to name a couple for Keto examples. Their newer location is convenient (their own parking + outside seating) and so much bigger, which allowed for the selection and product expansion. I usually stock up on a bunch of goodies since I don't live in the area. What's good? I highly recommend the keto breakfast sandwich - really hits the spot. The coffee wasn't for me (I got a latte as a combo with the bfast sandwich - wouldn't get it again). I love the pies - peanut butter or cookie butter, and the truffle bombs. The selection rotates and most recently I enjoyed the white chocolate peppermint Christmas tree cake. Service is always sooo nice! My only request for future improvement is better coffee/espresso drinks :) and maybe some inside seating.

Алина

5.09 months ago

I’m not a keto follower, however, decided to give it a try as I craved quality not grocery store pumpkin pie and chocolate cheesecake. The pumpkin cheesecake was absolutely delicious as well as the chocolate French silk cheesecake. I will definitely be back! The assortment is so large that is no one in Madison offers this and the quality you won’t find anywhere else within Madison boundaries. Highly recommend, the almond flower crust was very very good and I’d prefer almond flour now to regular flour because of this introduction. Very clean and organized space, it is apparent that everything is fresh, made with love and care. Disregard mean reviews. This is a small business and they work hard to be able to offer this assortment to Madisonians. Delivery and pick up available the same day.