Gotham Bagels

Elle Arjee

5.02 months ago

Best bagels ever!!! The drive home all I could smell was the garlic bagels was drooling 🤤 got the babka as well very delicious!!! Same with the smoked salmon cream cheese!!! Very nice staff and you can tell the owner cares a lot about his business!! Super clean and fantastic food!!

Michael Luy

5.03 months ago

My go-to spot for bagels in Madison. All of the sandwiches that I've tried are great. It can be very hectic and busy inside so I usually try and order ahead of time.

E Friedman

5.04 months ago

We’ve used Gotham Bagels for catering twice now, and both experiences have been outstanding. The food is consistently delicious and beautifully presented—people always ask where we got the catering from! The bagels are so good, and the platters are both impressive and really generous in size. Everything arrived fresh, looked great, and tasted even better. The pasta salad and tuna salad were also really good and got a lot of compliments. They were easy to work with and very accommodating, which made the whole process smooth. After the first time we used them, the owner even called to check in and make sure everything went well, which we really appreciated. We wouldn’t hesitate to use them again and highly recommend them for any catering needs!

Dave Cameron

5.010 months ago

I went twice; once for breakfast and once for lunch. At 8:00 AM - I was the only one in the place and got fast service. At 1:00 PM - it was packed and I had 20 orders in front of me. You get choices of 20 different bagel sandwiches (if you don't just get a bagel) with several choices of bagel and several choices of cream cheese. Easy to nearly "make your own". Good sized and good value for the money.

Marco Estrada-Gomez

2.0a year ago

Gotham Bagels has a really nice atmosphere and the food itself is genuinely tasty, which makes this review a bit tough, but unfortunately, our overall experience just didn’t live up to expectations. We went on a Saturday, so I expected a bit of a wait, but we ended up waiting about an hour for just three bagels, which felt excessive. Still, I was willing to overlook that until we got home and found that all three bagels were made on the wrong kind of bread. We had ordered two on everything bagels and one on garlic, but received what looked like whole wheat or something similar definitely not what we asked for. What really brought the experience down was the lack of communication; if they were out of the bagels we ordered, a quick heads-up would’ve gone a long way. Instead, we were left confused and a bit underwhelmed. Great flavor, but the poor service and incorrect order made it hard to justify more than two stars.